LONDON (Reuters Breakingviews) – Masayoshi Son’s SoftBank Group is a big tech-investment machine whose gears are greased by beneficiant dollops of debt. Borrowing labored nicely for the $80 billion firm as asset values rose; it may grow to be an issue as they back down.
Japan’s SoftBank Group Corp Chief Government Masayoshi Son attends a information convention in Tokyo, Japan, November 5, 2018.
On Son’s most popular measures, SoftBank’s debt burden appears manageable. The Japanese billionaire desires to maintain borrowing beneath one-quarter of the worth of its property, which embody stakes in e-commerce group Alibaba, two telecom operators, chipmaker Arm and a bit of the $100 billion Imaginative and prescient Fund. On that depend he has a cushty margin of security: internet debt was $45 billion on the finish of June, or simply 17% of his portfolio’s $260 billion price, utilizing market costs for the listed stakes and SoftBank’s estimates for its non-public holdings. Money readily available covers no less than two years of bond repayments, whereas money flows have been greater than twice annual curiosity funds within the 12 months to June.
These measures don’t inform the total story, nevertheless. To start out, Son’s telecom subsidiaries – America’s Dash and Japan’s SoftBank Corp – have collectively borrowed about $90 billion. Legally the debt is non-recourse, which implies SoftBank may stroll away with out being pursued by offended collectors. Nevertheless it’s onerous to think about Son ever washing his fingers of Dash. Doing so would wipe out over a tenth of the Japanese group’s asset worth and make it more durable for different models to borrow in future.
Certainly, Son lately used SoftBank’s stability sheet to bail out workplace sublessor WeWork. Credit score buyers are apt to wonder if rescuing cash-burning investees is a contingent legal responsibility.
There’s one other layer of leverage in Son’s $100 billion Imaginative and prescient Fund, which owns stakes in loss-making firms like Uber Applied sciences. About $40 billion of the funding car’s capital is in most popular shares which pay a 7% annual coupon to buyers like Saudi Arabia’s Public Funding Fund. Although it’s not strictly debt, Son has to honour these funds earlier than rewarding his personal shareholders. The fund has additionally signed offers with banks permitting it to borrow as much as $four.1 billion towards a few of its investments, partly to assist pay these coupons. That magnifies the draw back if the portfolio stumbles.
Lastly, there’s Son himself. The 62-year-old tycoon has pledged 38% of his $18 billion SoftBank stake as collateral for private loans, Bloomberg reported, and he accounts for many of the $5 billion SoftBank has lent staff to spend money on the Imaginative and prescient Fund. Which means each he and the father or mother group are extra geared to the car’s efficiency.
Even utilizing Son’s slender internet debt definition, SoftBank’s borrowings are extra burdensome than they give the impression of being. The official loan-to-value ratio is premised on a puffed-up portfolio. For instance, the corporate values the 26% shareholding in Alibaba at its $120 billion market worth regardless that taxes on any disposal might be as much as 30%, Bernstein analysts reckon. Fairness buyers rightly take a extra sceptical view. SoftBank’s market worth is simply 38% of the touted worth of Son’s portfolio, after deducting debt.
The group’s means to satisfy future curiosity repayments can be much less stable than it appears to be like. SoftBank obtained about $four.5 billion in money from its portfolio firms within the 12 months to the top of June. This comfortably coated debt-servicing prices of about $2.1 billion. However that money got here from simply two sources. The primary was the Imaginative and prescient Fund, which paid $2 billion in administration charges and proceeds from the sale of holdings like chipmaker Nvidia. The second was SoftBank’s eponymous Japanese telecom enterprise, which paid its father or mother $2.5 billion in dividends.
Money proceeds from the Imaginative and prescient Fund are hardly dependable: demand for preliminary public choices of tech firms has cooled after the WeWork flop. If Son depended fully on funds from the native telecom enterprise, he would have little room for manoeuvre. Within the 12 months to June, SoftBank’s curiosity invoice was 82% of the dividends it obtained from the unit. SoftBank additionally faces a looming spike in debt repayments, with virtually $14 billion due within the subsequent three calendar years, utilizing Refinitiv information.
So what can Son do if he wants money? The excellent news is that he’s hardly in need of liquid property: promoting simply four% of Alibaba at its present value may cowl all SoftBank bonds falling due from 2020 to 2022, assuming a 30% tax price. The tycoon may additionally offload unlisted property like Arm, which he purchased for about $32 billion in 2016.
The dangerous information is compelled vendor not often will get a very good value. SoftBank is by far Alibaba’s largest shareholder; decreasing its stake would create a self-reinforcing overhang on the inventory. In the meantime Son’s monetary engineering would backfire as asset values fell. SoftBank’s internet debt is nearly two-fifths of its enterprise worth. A 20% fall within the worth of its portfolio ought to due to this fact ship the shares down by virtually a 3rd. At that time, Son’s big funding machine can be working in reverse.
Reuters Breakingviews is the world’s main supply of agenda-setting monetary perception. Because the Reuters model for monetary commentary, we dissect the large enterprise and financial tales as they break world wide day-after-day. A worldwide staff of about 30 correspondents in New York, London, Hong Kong and different main cities offers knowledgeable evaluation in actual time.
Join a free trial of our full service at https://www.breakingviews.com/trial and comply with us on Twitter @Breakingviews and at www.breakingviews.com. All opinions expressed are these of the authors.